Vikings’ Aaron Rodgers Saga Nears End as Steelers Move Into Pole Position
By Evan Massey | Published May 23, 2025, at 12:45 PM EDT | Newsweek Sports
After months of rampant speculation, swirling rumors, and intense debate across sports media, the saga surrounding future Hall of Fame quarterback Aaron Rodgers and his potential return to the NFL is edging closer to resolution. While the Pittsburgh Steelers appear to be the frontrunners, a fresh update has all but confirmed that the Minnesota Vikings, once viewed as a tantalizing destination, are officially out of the race.
According to recent reports and commentary from ESPN NFL insider Jeremy Fowler during an appearance on the Dan Patrick Show, Rodgers’ connection to the Vikings may have never been as solid as it appeared. Despite early offseason buzz tying the legendary quarterback to Minnesota, the franchise has apparently doubled down on its commitment to first-round rookie J.J. McCarthy.
From New York to Limbo
Rodgers, now 41, entered the 2025 offseason as one of the most enigmatic figures in professional football. After a turbulent and injury-shortened 2024 season with the New York Jets—marked by a devastating Achilles injury on just the fourth snap of the season—Rodgers opted not to retire, fueling rumors that he might seek a final chapter with a contender.
The Minnesota Vikings, armed with a promising roster, elite playmakers like Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison, and offensive guru Kevin O’Connell at the helm, seemed like an ideal landing spot. Insiders hinted that Rodgers himself was drawn to the stability and creativity of O’Connell’s system, and the appeal of playing in nine dome games—an important consideration for an aging quarterback managing wear and tear.
Vikings Shut the Door
However, according to Fowler, that ship has sailed.
“There’s some teams I’ve talked to, they are still kind of wondering, like, is he just waiting out the Vikings, you know?” Fowler said. “Because the Vikings would be an ideal scenario—one of the best play callers in the league in Kevin O’Connell, nine dome games… But I checked in with the Vikings. I still don’t expect that. They’re moving forward with J.J. McCarthy.”
That assertion closes the book on what would have been a historic pairing. Rodgers donning purple and gold would not only have reignited his career in a system tailored to his strengths but also allowed him to face his former team, the Green Bay Packers, twice in 2025. That potential for high-stakes, high-drama revenge games stirred excitement among fans and analysts alike. But the Vikings’ commitment to youth and development ultimately won out.
Turning the Page to Pittsburgh—or Retirement
With Minnesota off the table, Rodgers’ options are narrowing rapidly. The Steelers remain the most viable suitor, but a deal has yet to materialize. For weeks, Pittsburgh has been widely considered the frontrunner, with a ready-made defense, a solid offensive line, and a leadership culture capable of absorbing a personality like Rodgers’.
And yet, as June approaches, there’s no contract.
Some have attributed the delay to Rodgers’ personal life. Others suggest the delay is tactical—that Rodgers is surveying the league one last time to see if an unforeseen contender, or dream destination, opens a spot.
Whatever the cause, Fowler warns that the sands are quickly running out: “So he really has no other option, other than Pittsburgh or retiring.”
Rodgers’ Legacy in Limbo
Rodgers’ legacy is secure—four NFL MVP awards, a Super Bowl title, and nearly two decades of highlight-reel dominance are more than enough to ensure his place in Canton. But the manner in which he chooses to close out his career could significantly impact how the league and fans remember him.
Will he go out quietly, with a final season in Pittsburgh—perhaps competing with Russell Wilson for the starting job and mentoring Kenny Pickett—or will he retire, ending his story with the brief and unfortunate New York chapter?
Alternatively, will another team emerge from the shadows at the eleventh hour?
While highly unlikely, the NFL has been known for last-minute twists. Quarterback injuries during offseason activities, preseason, or even early regular-season weeks could change the quarterback landscape and potentially make room for Rodgers to re-enter the conversation in unexpected places.
A New Era in Minnesota
Meanwhile, the Vikings are moving full steam ahead with McCarthy, the 10th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. The Michigan product has impressed in rookie minicamp, with coaches lauding his poise, work ethic, and command of the playbook.
The decision to bypass Rodgers in favor of McCarthy signals a philosophical shift for the franchise. Rather than opting for a short-term splash, the Vikings are investing in stability and long-term growth.
“J.J. has shown us everything we hoped for and more,” head coach Kevin O’Connell said in a post-minicamp presser earlier this week. “His leadership, his presence in the locker room, and his ability to pick up what we do on offense—all of it suggests he’s ready to be our guy. We’re committed to building something sustainable.”
Steelers Pressure Mounts
Back in Pittsburgh, the pressure is rising. With mandatory minicamp beginning June 10, Steelers brass are eager for clarity. Rumors swirl that Mike Tomlin has already given Rodgers a soft deadline, emphasizing the need for stability at the game’s most important position.
NFL insider Adam Schefter recently added fuel to the fire by suggesting Rodgers could make a decision “within days, not weeks.”
“The Steelers want a decision soon. They’re not interested in dragging this into training camp,” Schefter reported. “If Rodgers is going to commit, it needs to happen now.”
End of the Road?
If no team makes a viable offer—or if Rodgers simply doesn’t feel the fire anymore—retirement looms.
It would be a bittersweet exit for one of the game’s most iconic figures. While his final years were marred by injury and drama, his overall impact on the sport remains profound.
Rodgers revolutionized the quarterback position with his mechanics, mobility, and uncanny ability to extend plays. His deep throws, audibles, and leadership under pressure defined an era in Green Bay, and his name remains synonymous with greatness.
Whether or not he walks away in 2025, or suits up for one more run in black and gold, one thing is certain: The NFL is bracing for a new chapter—one with or without Aaron Rodgers.
—
For more breaking updates on Aaron Rodgers, the Minnesota Vikings, and all things NFL, stay with Newsweek Sports.
Subscribe to go ad-free and never miss a headline.
Follow Evan Massey for insider NFL analysis.
