Paul Mullin Faces Familiar Competition: Star Striker to Compete Against Former Wrexham Teammates at Wigan Athletic
In what could be one of the most intriguing transfer sagas of the summer, Wrexham AFC’s talismanic striker Paul Mullin is reportedly on the brink of a sensational move to Wigan Athletic. However, this potential switch comes with an unexpected twist — Mullin may find himself battling against not only new teammates but also two of his former Wrexham comrades for one major individual prize: the League One Golden Boot.
The development, if finalized, would see Mullin depart the Racecourse Ground following a historic three-season spell during which he helped catapult the club from the National League to League One, capturing the hearts of fans and attracting international attention thanks to the club’s celebrity owners, Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney. But in what might be seen as a bittersweet move, Mullin could now be set to spearhead Wigan Athletic’s attacking line as they aim to challenge for promotion in the 2025/26 season.
A Triangular Clash of Former Dragons
If the deal is completed, Mullin would reunite — or rather, compete — with two former Wrexham players who are now with Wigan: striker Billy Waters and winger Jordan Ponticelli. Both players previously donned the red shirt of Wrexham and have since found new life at the DW Stadium. Now, all three could find themselves vying not only for team success but also for personal glory.
The League One Golden Boot is one of the most sought-after individual accolades in English football’s third tier. For Mullin, Waters, and Ponticelli, the battle is more than just about goals — it’s about legacy, redemption, and proving themselves at a crucial moment in their careers.
The Legacy of Paul Mullin at Wrexham
Paul Mullin’s legacy at Wrexham is already secure. Since joining the club from Cambridge United in 2021 — a shocking transfer at the time given Wrexham’s non-league status — Mullin has become an icon. In his debut season, he scored 28 league goals, earning the National League Golden Boot. He followed this with another incredible campaign, netting 38 goals in all competitions during the 2022/23 season and guiding the Red Dragons to a long-awaited return to the Football League.
In 2023/24, Mullin continued his stellar form despite injury setbacks, ending the season as Wrexham’s top scorer once again with 22 goals in League Two. His name became synonymous with the club’s meteoric rise, and he was often described as the beating heart of Phil Parkinson’s attack.
However, recent reports suggest that Mullin is keen for a new challenge, and the lure of Wigan Athletic — a club with Premier League history and aspirations of returning to the Championship — may be too tempting to resist.
Why Wigan?
Wigan Athletic offers Mullin a unique opportunity. The club, currently undergoing a rebuilding phase following financial turmoil and a recent change in ownership, has made it clear that it intends to return to English football’s upper echelons. With new investment, managerial stability under Shaun Maloney, and a young core mixed with experienced heads, Wigan seems poised to challenge for promotion in the upcoming League One season.
According to sources close to the situation, Wigan have been monitoring Mullin for several months. With his proven goal-scoring record, leadership qualities, and unmatched work ethic, he ticks all the boxes for a club looking to reignite its fortunes.
Moreover, Wigan’s style of play — a high-press, quick-transition game — could suit Mullin’s tenacious playing style perfectly. The move would also allow Mullin to remain in the North West of England, close to his family, a factor that could further sway his decision.
Familiar Faces: Waters and Ponticelli
Billy Waters, who played a brief but impactful role at Wrexham during the 2022/23 season, has already found success at Wigan. Despite initially being seen as a squad player, Waters surprised many by finishing last season with 15 goals in all competitions. His versatility and ability to play across the front three have made him a fan favorite.
Jordan Ponticelli, another former Wrexham player, has had a more winding path. After leaving Wrexham in 2021, he spent time in the lower leagues before revitalizing his career at Wigan. Last season, he impressed with his pace, directness, and improved finishing, scoring 12 goals and providing 7 assists.
The potential arrival of Mullin could create a fierce but friendly internal competition — one that could elevate the entire squad. For fans, it’s a tantalizing prospect: three ex-Wrexham forwards, once teammates, now competing to be the top marksman in League One.
What This Means for Wrexham
Mullin’s departure would undeniably leave a void at Wrexham. His goals, charisma, and connection with the supporters have been pivotal to the club’s renaissance. Replacing him would be no small feat.
Manager Phil Parkinson would be under pressure to secure a forward capable of matching Mullin’s prolific output. Early names linked include Luke Armstrong from Harrogate Town and James Norwood of Oldham Athletic. The club’s Hollywood ownership, no strangers to dramatic moves, may also seek a marquee signing to maintain momentum and keep global eyes on North Wales.
However, Wrexham has always prided itself on collective strength rather than individual stardom. With the likes of Elliot Lee, Ollie Palmer, and Sam Dalby still in the squad, the Red Dragons would not be lacking in firepower — though Mullin’s leadership and finishing would be sorely missed.
A Personal and Professional Battle
For Mullin, this potential move represents more than a new club — it is a fresh chapter. The hunger to prove himself at a higher level, especially after missing out on significant game time due to injury last season, could be the driving force behind his decision.
Facing off against Waters and Ponticelli adds another layer of intrigue. All three players have similar backgrounds: underdogs with something to prove, players who have weathered the volatility of lower-league football and come out stronger. Their battle for the League One Golden Boot — should they all stay fit and start regularly — could be one of the stories of the season.
Fans across Wrexham and Wigan, as well as neutral observers, would have ample reason to watch the race unfold. For Mullin, the opportunity to add a League One Golden Boot to his already impressive personal honors list would be a testament to his unrelenting drive.
Conclusion
While the deal is yet to be finalized, the potential implications of Paul Mullin joining Wigan Athletic are vast. From rekindling old relationships to igniting new rivalries, the move could reshape the League One landscape.
Whether Mullin lifts the Golden Boot, helps Wigan push for promotion, or simply proves that his talent knows no bounds beyond Wrexham, one thing is certain — wherever he goes, he brings goals, passion, and a story worth telling.
For now, Wrexham fans wait with bated breath, and Wigan supporters dream of a future led by a goal machine with a Dragon’s heart. Whatever the outcome, the 2025/26 League One season just became a whole lot more exciting.
